Stone Cold Touch
Jennifer L. Armentrout
The Dark Elements, book 2
Average Goodreads rating4.2
- Found Family
- Gods and Demons
Book 1 in The Eating Woods
by Keri Lake
We independently select and recommend books. Purchases made through our links may earn us a commission, at no extra cost to you. Prices and availability are set by each retailer.
Anathema by Keri Lake is a dark gothic romance of forbidden desire, religious corruption, and love that defies doctrine, guilt, and damnation.
Tagged on the series as a whole, so not every book will feature each one.
Anathema by Keri Lake is a provocative work of Dark Romance steeped in gothic atmosphere, religious symbolism, and emotionally intense taboo love. Haunting and psychologically charged, the novel explores what happens when devotion, desire, and damnation collide - and when love itself is branded a sin.
Set within an oppressive environment shaped by faith, hierarchy, and repression, Anathema centres on characters trapped beneath rigid moral structures. The world Lake creates is claustrophobic and heavy with unspoken rules, where guilt is weaponised and obedience is prized above compassion. Institutions meant to offer salvation instead become sources of control, creating fertile ground for secrecy, rebellion, and obsession.
Romance in Anathema is explicitly forbidden. Love develops in the shadow of doctrine, shame, and consequence, making every moment of intimacy feel dangerous. Lake leans fully into taboo romance, allowing desire to unfold slowly through proximity, restraint, and emotional vulnerability. The tension is relentless - built not on spectacle, but on what must remain hidden.
Magic, when present, is subtle and symbolic rather than overt. Power manifests through belief, ritual, and psychological dominance rather than spells, reinforcing the theme that faith itself can be a form of magic - one capable of healing or destroying. This creates a chilling examination of power rooted in belief, where control is enforced through fear of punishment rather than physical force.
The characters in Anathema are deeply flawed and morally grey, shaped by trauma, indoctrination, and longing. Lake refuses to offer simple redemption arcs; instead, she allows growth to emerge through painful self-awareness and difficult choices. Love does not erase guilt - it intensifies it, forcing characters to confront the cost of wanting something they are not meant to have.
Atmosphere is central to the novel’s impact. Lake’s prose is evocative and immersive, rich with gothic imagery - stone halls, candlelit spaces, whispered prayers, and silence heavy with judgment. The darkness is psychological rather than gratuitous, creating a slow-building dread that mirrors the characters’ internal conflict.
A key theme of Anathema is identity versus indoctrination. Characters must decide whether obedience defines morality - or whether choosing love, even at great personal cost, is its own form of truth. The novel interrogates the idea of sin, asking who gets to define it and who benefits when desire is condemned.
Anathema is ideal for readers who seek Romance that pushes boundaries - emotionally intense, morally complex, and unapologetically dark. Gothic, taboo, and deeply unsettling, the novel stands as a powerful example of Keri Lake’s ability to explore love at its most dangerous, where devotion and defiance are inseparable.
Jennifer L. Armentrout
The Dark Elements, book 2
Average Goodreads rating4.2
Adalyn Grace
Belladonna, book 2
Average Goodreads rating4.1
Rachel Gillig
The Stonewater Kingdom, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.5
Jay Kristoff
Empire of the Vampire, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.7
RuNyx
Average Goodreads rating4.3
Kerri Maniscalco
Prince of Sin, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.0
Still Looking?
Further down our similarity list, but still sharing tropes and genres with this book.
John Gwynne
Of Blood & Bone, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.6
Buy from Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)N. K. Jemisin
Dreamblood, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.3
Buy from Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)Sarah J. Maas
A Court of Thorns and Roses (ACOTAR), book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.5
Buy from Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)Keri Lake is a dark romance author known for gothic atmospheres, taboo love stories, and emotionally intense novels where desire, trauma, and obsession collide.
Books, series and tropes by Keri LakeIf you devoured Anathema's gothic atmosphere, morally grey anti-hero, and all-consuming romance, discover 13 dark fantasy romances with the same addictive blend of danger, obsession, and devotion.
Occasional emails with new recommendations, series news and trope round-ups.