From Blood and Ash
Jennifer L. Armentrout
Blood And Ash, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.6
Book 2 in The Crimson Moth
We independently select and recommend books. Purchases made through our links may earn us a commission, at no extra cost to you. Prices and availability are set by each retailer.
The Rebel Witch by Kristen Ciccarelli is a dark fantasy romance of hidden magic and rising rebellion, where love and defiance collide in a world built to destroy witches.
Tagged on the series as a whole, so not every book will feature each one.
The Rebel Witch by Kristen Ciccarelli is a dark, emotionally charged fantasy romance that expands the world and conflict of The Crimson Moth series. Where secrecy once ensured survival, this novel shifts the balance toward resistance, exploring the cost of defiance in a society defined by fear, persecution, and control.
Set in a world where witches are hunted and magic is treated as a contagion, the story follows characters who can no longer afford to remain hidden. Systems designed to erase magic tighten their grip, forcing those with power to make an impossible choice: submit, flee, or fight back. Ciccarelli builds a tense atmosphere where rebellion grows not from heroism, but from exhaustion and loss.
At the heart of the novel is a powerful exploration of identity and agency. Characters who once survived through silence must now decide who they are willing to become when secrecy fails. Magic is no longer just something to hide - it becomes a statement, a threat, and a call to action. Each act of defiance carries consequence, reinforcing the idea that power always demands sacrifice.
Romance remains central, but it evolves alongside the broader conflict. Relationships are tested by betrayal, shifting loyalties, and the realities of war. Forbidden romance deepens into something more dangerous: love that openly defies the systems built to destroy it. Ciccarelli uses emotional intimacy as both refuge and vulnerability, ensuring that connection heightens the stakes rather than softening them.
The novel continues the series’ commitment to morally grey characters. Hunters, rulers, rebels, and witches alike are shaped by indoctrination, fear, and survival instinct. No side is free of blood or compromise. This ambiguity gives the rebellion weight, showing that overthrowing an oppressive system does not erase the damage it has caused.
Themes of rebellion against authority and love versus duty dominate the narrative. Characters must choose between personal safety and collective freedom, between protecting those they love and fighting for a future that may never come. Victory is uncertain, and progress is fragile, making every decision feel costly and earned.
The Rebel Witch is ideal for readers who enjoy Fantasy with strong Romance elements, particularly stories about witch hunts, resistance movements, and emotionally intense relationships forged under pressure. Dark, defiant, and deeply personal, the novel captures the moment when survival turns into resistance - and when love becomes an act of revolution.
Jennifer L. Armentrout
Blood And Ash, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.6
Kerri Maniscalco
Prince of Sin, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.0
Alex Aster
Lightlark, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.0
Adalyn Grace
Belladonna, book 2
Average Goodreads rating4.1
Shelby Mahurin
Serpent & Dove, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.3
Penn Cole
The Kindred's Curse Saga, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.4
Still Looking?
Further down our similarity list, but still sharing tropes and genres with this book.
Taylor Jenkins Reid
Average Goodreads rating4.6
Holly Black
Modern Faerie Tale, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.8
Buy from Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)Stephanie Garber
Caraval, book 1
Average Goodreads rating4.2
Buy from Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)Kristen Ciccarelli is a fantasy author known for emotionally driven stories featuring dragons, forbidden magic, morally complex characters, and high-stakes romance.
Books, series and tropes by Kristen CiccarelliThe Rebel Witch
Buy from Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)Occasional emails with new recommendations, series news and trope round-ups.